Seventeen-year-old Jamie Dorfman has spurned the pool and the
mall, opting instead to spend the waning weeks of her summer
vacation honing her admissions essay for Syracuse University.
Between sessions with her private college-admissions coach, the
Cherry Hill High School East senior and about 100 others are
spending afternoons at her school this week with their English
teachers, learning the art of the all-important college essay.
Dorfman and stressed seniors like her are increasingly turning to
school programs, private coaches, and online essay services as they
search for the perfect essay - 500 words that ooze so much brains
and personality that their applications soar to the top of a sea of
perfect grades and high SAT scores.
"The essays are everything, and mine still needs some work,"
Dorfman said as she waited for teacher Julie Bathke to review her
draft at the essay workshop. "The SATs say nothing about my
personality."
Each year, admissions officials say, they seek new ways to
measure students' ability to communicate, requiring as many as 10
short essays, the SAT II writing exam, and, starting in 2005, a new
essay segment on the SAT.
"I think it comes back to the fact that the ability to express
yourself verbally is integral to the college experience," said Lee
Stetson, dean of admissions for the University of Pennsylvania.
But Stetson said he regretted the growth of the cottage industry
of online services and high school workshops that focus on those
very essays.
"This essay business has gotten a little out of hand," he said.
"We don't want students to be trained. We want them to write
naturally and hear their own voice. If something sounds like it was
written by a 45-year-old attorney, it probably was."
Teachers at the Cherry Hill East workshop said their intent was
to help students release their voices - and eliminate cliches.
"You want this to be an essay that only you can write,"
Marguerite Smaldore, coordinator of the workshop, instructed
students Tuesday as they analyzed a sample essay in which the writer
confessed she still sucked her thumb. "Use humor and anecdotes to
convey your epiphany, the lesson you've learned."
Once school starts, Smaldore said, she will ask students in her
English classes to write another essay draft. "We want our students
to write wow essays," she said.
At Central Bucks High School West in Doylestown, essay help is
the domain of guidance counselors such as Ginny Barrett, who sets up
appointments with seniors and parents to evaluate an application
before it is sent. Barrett said she had 100 such meetings in the
spring and expected more this fall.
But not all schools can offer these services, and that has fueled
a boom in online editing services. With names such as
EssayAdvice.com, WritingWeb.com, Accepted.com and EssayEdge.com,
these services charge between $50 and $500 to edit essays and review
applications. On its Web site, IvyEssays.com offers to buy and sell
successful essays.
Geoff Cook, 25, founder of EssayEdge.com, said he started his
business in 1997, when he was a Harvard University freshman, after
recognizing that many students had no one to review their essays. He
earned $10,000 his first year and now employs 300 people to edit
7,000 essays a year. His business was purchased last year by
Peterson's, the college information empire.
"Schools are placing increasing importance on the art of
writing," Cook said. "At the end of the day, students are competing
with people with all the same grades and SAT scores as they have,
and Harvard turns down 1,600 valedictorians a year."
Cook said he was "99 percent sure" that admissions officials
could not detect his professional fingerprints on the applicants'
essays.
"We're not writing the essay for students. We're helping them
write a better essay than they did before," he said.
At Cherry Hill East, Bathke estimated that at least 20 percent of
her English students sought online help or hired college coaches and
tutors.
Because more parents want students to stay closer to home,
"getting into East Coast colleges seems to be so much harder since
the Sept. 11 attacks," she said. "If all other things are equal, it
depends on the essay to tip the balance" for admission.
Senior Adam Cohen, 17, said he hoped his essay on the importance
of music in his life would give him the edge to get into Cornell
University or Vanderbilt University.
"When I wrote my first draft, it was full of things I know now I
shouldn't do, like use cliches," said Cohen, who sings and plays the
guitar in his band, Duco Project. "My mother is always saying that
music doesn't pay the bills, but maybe it will get me into
college."